Discover more from Nathan Winograd
For the love of dog
Someone I know (through their work) recently lost their dog to cardiac arrest. The dog died in his arms. He is hurting. Those of us blessed with dogs understand the deep pain he is in, but somehow, expressions of sorrow and sympathy, even for those of us who have experienced it and as important as they are to convey, do not quite grasp the depths of that suffering; the inability to get an aching heart to rest.
I’ve had many dogs in my life. I wear a dog tag with all their names, so they always stay close to my heart. Though Topham, one of my dogs, died in 2010, and Pickles, his brother, four years later, I dreamt about them the other night. I woke my wife, sleeping next to me, to tell her, “I saw the Boys.” She asked me how they were.
This is what I wrote for Pickles (pictured here) on his 14th birthday, just a few months before he died:
Today is my dog’s 14th birthday. Pickles has been my constant companion for all but seven weeks of his life. I adopted him and his brother Topham together many years ago. They were the last two pups of a litter born at the San Francisco SPCA on July 1, 1999. Their mother was due to be spayed in the low-cost clinic, when she gave birth in the shelter the night before. My views were much less enlightened back then, or I would have lobbied for an end to spaying obviously pregnant animals. In the case of Pickles and his littermates, the veterinarian would have been required to remove each of the puppies, one by one, and inject them with a lethal dose of barbiturates. Killing is killing, even if the puppies are not “technically” born. But there they were, five beautiful little wiggly chunks, and seven weeks later, I decided to adopt one of them.
The shelter’s dog trainer was with me. Pickles and his brother, Topham, were the last two of the group. As I sat on the ground, his brother came running toward me, climbed on top of me, wiggling his whole body in delight. Pickles stayed back, eyeing me suspiciously. It took a lot of coaxing to get him to come to me. The trainer recommended I adopt Topham. “That one,” she said pointing to Pickles, “will give you trouble.” I didn’t need to hear anymore. I was sold, but not in the way she intended. He needed me. So I adopted Pickles on the spot. I also adopted Topham. How could I leave him behind? And for 12 years, “Pick-Pick” and “Top-Top” were seldom apart, from each other and from me. When Top-Top died in 2010, Pickles took in pretty hard. More than that, it seemed to have aged him–a lot.
I doubt that is true. The fact of the matter is that I didn’t have Topham to compare him to and that showed me Pickles as he truly was. Because while Topham was old; Pickles appeared young by comparison. While Topham had been sick for a while; Pickles remained healthy. While Topham slowly climbed the stairs from the ground floor; Pickles bounded up them. When Topham needed to be carried up the stairs; Pickles continued up and down. When Topham couldn’t wait outside to go to the bathroom and started having accidents in the house; Pickles dutifully waited. When Topham slept by the bed because he could no longer get up and down it; Pickles could still leap in and out of the minivan. But when Topham died, Pickles seemed to grow old overnight.
At 14 years old, I suppose I shouldn’t be surprised. But I don’t need to look at a calendar. Aside from the daily regimen of pills I have to hide in his food, you can see it on his face: the gray muzzle, the cloudy eyes, the lines on his face, the heavy breathing. Last year, for the first time in the five years we’ve lived in our home, he couldn’t make the loop on our walk that had been our daily routine. Barely into it, before we hit the long hill going up, he stopped smelling things, he started panting, his face became focused, and he fell behind. I turned around and we went home. He slept all afternoon. Now, the walks are only a distant memory; his back legs are too stiff, arthritis having taken over. To go anywhere–from my office to the kitchen, from the living room to the bedroom–I have to hold him up with a sling. I carry him up the stairs and I help him go down them. When he goes to the bathroom, he sometimes falls, so I hold him up, too. Not a day goes by where he doesn’t have an accident in the house. And though Pickles is deeply loved by my wife and is around her and the kids 24/7 when I travel, he suffers when I am out of town, watching the door, hoping for my return. I wonder if he knows our remaining time together is not as long as it once was.
When he sleeps, his body is pressed against mine and I feel for him in the middle of the night, laying my hand on his chest to feel the rhythmic up and down that lets me know he’s still there. A couple of times, I found myself whispering in his ear, asking him to please not leave me. The thought of his death fills me with dread.
After Topham died, I still found myself looking for him, sometimes calling him from the dark when I woke up, quiet and careful not to wake my wife. “Come on Boys,” I’d say softly, but only Pickles would be there to heed the call. Soon, not even he will answer. How could that be?
I became a No Kill advocate because to me, death is the ultimate cruelty; a frightening emptiness that leaves nothing but pain for those of us left behind. How is it possible that someone you could love so deeply, someone who defines your place in this world–your wife, a parent, a child, your dog–can suddenly be gone; someone who you will never see again. A voice you will no longer hear. Forever. When I think of how callously lives are ended in what we euphemistically call “shelters,” how cavalierly they are killed, sometimes cruelly and without a moment’s hesitation; animals who were once as deeply loved as Pickles is or animals who were never even given a name, I feel grief. And anger. It’s unthinkable that we would allow this to continue, creating voids that can never be filled.
I suppose some think it macabre to entertain such thoughts, but I can’t help it. I live at home, I work from home, and he is there, every minute of every day, my shadow. And when I think about Pickles just a few years ago, how boundless his energy was, how many times he would chase and retrieve a ball, how far he could walk, yanking on the leash to get here and there, how he used to greet me by putting his front legs on my shoulders, standing tall on his two back legs, looking at me eye to eye, I am overcome with a sense of loss. He can’t do those things anymore. I can still see it in him, he wants to jump up to greet me, shoulder-to-shoulder, eye-to-eye, so he can lick my face, but his legs no longer leave the ground and he knows it is no use. He remains on the ground. So I bend down, getting to his level for our greeting, eye-to-eye just like always; to show him our embrace still works. But for how long?
When I let my mind think about losing Pickles, I literally become blind as my eyes fill up with tears. Even as I write this, I have to wipe them away. And so I am trying to train myself not to. Trying not to think about what once was or what might be, but about what we have today.
We draw our inspiration from wherever it comes; from philosophy. From a poem. A song. Even from a cartoon; from Oogway, the wise, old turtle in Kung Fu Panda. “You are too concerned about what was and what will be,” he tells Po. “There is a saying: yesterday is history, tomorrow is a mystery, but today is a gift. That is why it is called the ‘present.'” And that is how I try to think about my remaining time with Pickles; a gift to cherish every single day. I sit at my desk and type, and he sits near me on his bed. Occasionally, we’ll take a break and get some fresh air. At night, I lift him onto the couch and then we sit together, his head on my lap, watching television. Or I’ll read or play with the kids, with Pickles right there with us. I suppose I am practicing a sort of doggy meditation, trying to stay in the present, relishing every day I have with him. Forcing my mind to stay focused, as I play a game I know I will lose; trying to stave off for as long as possible the finish line in order to protect the heart that knows someday, it will be ripped in half.
Who’s a good boy? Who? You are, my dear, Pickles. You. You. You. You. You.
To receive future articles and support my fight for the animals, please subscribe.