Nathan Winograd

Nathan Winograd

Share this post

Nathan Winograd
Nathan Winograd
ASPCA spends millions on salaries, little on animals
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More

ASPCA spends millions on salaries, little on animals

News and headlines for April 29 - May 5, 2023

Nathan Winograd's avatar
Nathan Winograd
May 05, 2023
∙ Paid
11

Share this post

Nathan Winograd
Nathan Winograd
ASPCA spends millions on salaries, little on animals
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
1
4
Share
The Detroit Police Department is on the defensive over their shooting of dogs. A new report finds that “Between 2020 and 2022, there were 100 shootings and 337 shots fired. Detroit police shot at 107 dogs and killed at least 74 of them.” That report determined that “Detroit officers are shooting at dogs more than three times as often” compared to other cities. Although the Assistant Police Chief defended his officers, saying, “I think we’re dealing well, with dogs,” it’s not true. Detroit police have a long history not only of shooting dogs but boasting about it. They have also had to settle cases for tens of thousands of dollars after bodycam footage proved officers were lying when they claimed the dogs charged at them.

These are some of the stories making headlines in animal protection:

Tucker is available for adoption and waiting for you at Burlington Animal Services, which runs the Alamance County, NC, shelter.

As more people turn to rescue and adoption and more shelters embrace progressive policies, the number of communities placing over 95% and as high as 99% of the animals is increasing. In North Carolina:

  • Polk County reported a 99% placement rate for dogs and 97% for cats.

  • Lincoln County reported a 96% placement rate for dogs, 96% for cats, and 96% for rabbits and other small pets.

  • Haywood County reported a 96% placement rate for cats, 93% for dogs, and 100% for rabbits and other small pets.

  • Rowan County reported a 95% placement rate for dogs, 95% for cats, and 90% for rabbits and other small pets.

  • Alamance County reported a 96% placement rate for cats and 93% for dogs.

And while even these communities can do better, they, other communities, and the national data prove that animals are not dying in pounds because there are too many, too few homes, or people don’t want the animals. They are dying because people in those pounds are killing them. Replace those people, implement the No Kill Equation, and we can be a No Kill nation today.


On July 8, 2022, two sheriff’s deputies “left their jurisdiction in Shasta County, drove over 500 miles at taxpayer expense, and crossed approximately six (6) separate county lines.” They were pursuing what they claimed was a “criminal case” involving “property” that was allegedly “stolen” or “embezzled.” 

The object of the search was Cedar, a pet goat. And the alleged perpetrator was a 9-year-old girl named E.L.

Cedar was part of a 4-H program where children raise and then sell the animals for slaughter. But E.L. came to love Cedar and did not want to part with him. Her desires would count for nothing. 

Putting aside that this was, at best, a small claims civil matter hardly worth the filing fee, the age of the girl, the object at issue (a pet goat who held no real market value but meant everything to the 9-year-old), the offer by her family to repay any costs, and in a state which has, in practice, decriminalized most theft-related offenses under Proposition 47, the offer of restitution should have ended the matter. 

Instead, the deputies would ultimately seize Cedar and turn him over to the Shasta District Fair, where he was apparently butchered and barbecued, leaving Cedar dead, E.L. traumatized, and 4-H’s creed of teaching truth, kindness, and sympathy in tatters.

E.L.’s family is now suing the Fair, the officers involved, and county officials in federal court for abusing their authority and violating the constitutional rights of the little girl.


A new report finds that “the ASPCA in 2021 had $390 million in revenue and $575 million in assets, including $310 million in investments and $105 million in savings,” but spent very little on helping animals in shelters, about 2%. 

Perhaps most striking, the animal welfare group has about $11 million in offshore accounts in the Caribbean, while tax filings show ASPCA CEO Matt Berkshadker rakes in nearly $1 million a year and 259 of his employees make six figures.

It is not the first report to question ASPCA finances. In 2021, CBS News did an exposé on the ASPCA, finding that the organization misleads people nationwide into donating because they think they run or fund local shelters. In the last 10 years, only 7% of the billions raised were used to help animals in other communities/with other SPCAs. The CBS report also found that most donations go back into fundraising. It also noted that ASPCA CEO Matt Bershadker makes well above the CEOs of other non-profits, including the Red Cross, which brings in 10 times the annual revenue.

Unfortunately, the current report and the earlier CBS one missed the bigger story: the ASPCA negligently, recklessly, and even intentionally harms the animals it fundraises on to protect. For example, the ASPCA caused or allowed:

  • The death of a little dog named Nyla and the emotional torment of the young woman who rescued her.

  • The death of 20 dogs in the back of their van while transporting them in extreme heat.

  • Dogs across New York City to starve to death.

  • Hundreds of thousands of animals to be killed despite rescue groups ready, willing, and able to save them.

And more.


This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Nathan J. Winograd
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share

Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More